"The Silence" Wastes Talented With a Derivative Plot and Shoddy Screenwriting

By: Keaton Marcus

DISCLAIMER: IF YOU ARE UNDER THE AGE OF 14, YOU MUST ASK YOUR PARENTS IF YOU ARE ALLOWED, IF THEY SAY NO…IT MEANS NO!

bildschirmfoto-2019-05-10-um-15-32-58-992x560.jpg

30/100 “sour”

Netflix is starting to really grow. After their monster-hit, "Bird Box" which debuted on the streaming website last year, they stuff the film industry with new films such as Beyonce's "Homecoming", "Isn't it Romantic", "The Perfect Date"--and much, much more. Most are successes, and a chunk of them have solid quality--and then there are the films that just plain out flop. The latter is a perfect example of John R. Leonetti's newest horror picture, "The Silence" which opened to Netflix in early-April, hoping to become a cult classic, especially when Academy Award winner Stanley Tucci stars in the picture.

Leonetti is known for directing low-budget horror movies such as 2014's "Annabelle", and 2017's "Wish Upon"--while he even produced "Insidious". Generally, his small, couple of films showcase a few scares--but in the end--land with a resounding thud. Then, Leonetti decided that it would be fun to completely rip-off 2018's "A Quiet Place", and the aforementioned "Bird Box" with "The Silence". The film feels like a prequel to those particular flicks, which could turn out interesting--but the plotting and storyline feel so contrived, and so compelled to create another hit, with a very similar background. The performances are occasionally strong, but the few action sequences, and especially the suspense--are lacking in great areas.

Despite the 90-minute run-time, audiences will still feel like watching a terrible, long epic-- if Leonetti and the crew were trying to make the doomed flick "fun", or "entertaining"--think again--the right response is pure boredom. The film starts off with Ally--a deaf, young girl who lives with her respectable family; and while the kick-off is from time to time promising, "The Silence" cuts right to the apocalypse during the first 15 minutes of the movie--turning the place from happy, little town to madness--terrorized by creatures that look like bats and birds combined with the monsters from the "Alien" franchise. Once again copy-catting the beasts from "A Quiet Place"--these certain creatures hunt with sound, as they are deaf--just like the leading character. In "A Quiet Place", one of the children is a deaf girl--who seems like the only hope for the family--in "The Silence"--it seems exactly the same.

As mentioned, the cast was led by the award-winning Stanley Tucci--who plays Hugh Andrews, the father. Clearly, "The Silence" was trying to create a father-daughter sub-plot between Tucci's Hugh and Shipka's Ally, which is again, dangerously close to John Krasinski's role in "A Quiet Place". The sub-plot never works well--generally courtesy of the dreary screenplay and dastardly derivative plotting. The result is that Stanley Tucci's performance is competent and occasionally impressive--but even the great actor cannot save a film less entertaining than watching cement dry. Even worse, another strong performance wasted is Kiernan Shipka's newest outing--and while the sign language is consistently clever--audiences can't help but compare her to many other horror film daughters. The remainder of the cast cannot help but squeak in a few words between the loud, watered down PG-13 violence.

The final verdict is: Netflix's "The Silence" features a pair of strong performances from Stanley Tucci and Kiernan Shipka--but even a talented cast cannot save the film from becoming a derivative, boring slog that suffers from a tired screenplay, and shoddy direction...$KIP IT

By: Keaton Marcus

There is no box office info because the film provided is produced by Netflix, released for streaming only.